By Zainab Shafiq 
The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) has put forward a strong recommendation for Yorkshire, proposing a £500,000 fine and significant points deductions across all formats in response to their mishandling of the Azeem Rafiq racism case.
During a hearing in London on Tuesday, Yorkshire admitted to four charges related to their inadequate handling of Rafiq’s case, the deletion of pertinent documents, and their failure to address racist language within the club over an extended period. This comes after six former Yorkshire employees were sanctioned in May for their use of a racist slur. However, former England captain Michael Vaughan was cleared of using discriminatory language towards a group of four Asian players, including Rafiq, before a T20 match in 2009.
To break down the suggested sanctions, the ECB proposes a £100,000 fine for mishandling the report, another £100,000 for wholesale data deletion, £150,000 for insufficient action regarding racist behavior, and an additional £150,000 for the systemic use of racist language over an extended period.
The recommended fine includes a suspension of £350,000 for three years, with the remaining £150,000 to be paid in installments from January to June 2024. These financial sanctions could have a significant impact on the club, as Yorkshire is currently facing a reported £3.5 million cash shortfall and has outstanding debt of £14.9 million to the Graves Trust.
The ECB’s lawyer, Jane Mulcahy, emphasized that the recommendations took Yorkshire’s financial situation into account and stated that it was not the intention of the ECB to put the club out of business. Sporting sanctions were deemed necessary due to the severity of the admissions, with a proposed 48-72 point deduction in the 2023 County Championship, a four-to-six point deduction in the 2023 One-Day Cup, and a four-to-six point deduction in the 2023 T20 Blast.
Responding to the proposed sanctions, Yorkshire’s lawyer, Daniel Stilitz, acknowledged that this had been a deeply regrettable chapter in the club’s history and reiterated their apologies to Mr. Rafiq. Stilitz argued that there was no evidence to suggest that the deletion of emails was related to the ongoing case and highlighted that Yorkshire had not ignored racist behavior from supporters in the past. He also emphasized the significant impact the events had already had on the club, including the loss of 11 sponsors and the financial implications of being unable to host international cricket.
Stilitz requested that any punishments imposed be suspended and stressed that the sanctions should not penalize those responsible. The Cricket Discipline Commission (CDC) will now review the recommendations and is expected to publish the written reasons for its decision within the next three to four weeks.
This ongoing process highlights the gravity of the situation and the need for comprehensive action to address racism in cricket. The cricketing community and fans are eagerly awaiting the CDC’s decision and the subsequent steps taken to ensure a more inclusive and equitable future for the sport.
Also, see:
Sehwag ready for battle with Shoaib Akhtar